SATA controller failure?

Disk Drives

Disk Drives
Disk Drives (Floppy, USB, HDD, CD/DVD/BD) discussion

SATA controller failure?

  • Hello All,
    I'm new to this forum and hope someone can help me with the following problem:
    About one year ago I purchased a Dimension 4700 directly from Dell.
    I bought a basic system and thus far added a second HD and two optical drives.
    First thing that went was the on board sound card after about 2 months. I didn't bother using my 90 day warranty on this and bought a sound card that I installed successfuly.
    About six months after buying the system, I started having problems booting the system up. Intermittantly, the system would fail to boot and give me the error massage: "no boot drive found"...trying to troubleshoot the system, I switched the SATA cables (I switched the ports, not the cables) between the two HD-drives and the system started to boot fine, but my secondary HD was not available anymore. So I concluded that the SATA conroller had failed.
    I ended up buying a new motherboard, installed it and everything worked fine. Until about a week ago.  Same problem as above, same solution: Switching SATA ports allows me to boot and run the system but I again lost my secondary HD.
    SO here are my questions:
    1) Is this truely th SATA controller failing or am I missing something?
    2) Is there a way to repair the controller or is the only solution a new motherboard?
    3) If I want to buy a new motherboard, can I but something non-Dell that would fit in my Dimension 4700 case? Is that what is determined by the form factor? And what would fit (Intel, ASUS, etc.)
    Any help is highly appreciated,
  • A faulty drive is another possibility; have you tested it?

    You can replace the onboard controller with a PCI SATA card.

    No, nothing but another Dell board will fit this case without major rewiring, cutting and drilling of sheet metal.