Print

On the sense and senselessness of Malware cleaning

Sign in
Sign in to post messages.
Latest post 12/18/2008 11:29 PM by joe53. 4 replies.
 
Page 1 of 1  
Muddy Yorkville
Joined on 06/07/2000
Posts: 4,997
Points 14,764

On the sense and senselessness of Malware cleaning

"Whether it even makes sense to clean infected computers is a topic of repeated heated discussion in the IT security world. Questions such as "Can I ever really trust a computer again once it has been infected?" or "Is it technically possible to completely clean a system?" always come to the forefront of these discussions."

 

Full read: http://www.emsisoft.com/en/kb/articles/tec081111/


This is a bit of an ad for a-squared, but it raises interesting questions. I haven't had to face this issue, and honestly do not know which route I would choose. Either way, the importance of backing up your data is emphasized. (I use Acronis to back up to an external HD).


Free Internet Security - WOT Web of Trust    Use OpenDNS    Get WinPatrol Free    MalwareBytes' Anti-Malware Free

  • Post Points: 50

4 Replies:

Joined on 02/11/2006
Posts: 17,261
Points 65,721

Re: On the sense and senselessness of Malware cleaning

Some systems do become horribly infected and are damaged beyond repair, but for the others, the trained helpers on the security forums have access to some very powerful tools for diagnosing and digging deeply to remove whatever signs of infection that are found. Their aim is to restore a system to its pre-infected working state without having to perform re-installation. 

Prevention is always better than spending days trying to clean once infected, and backups are a must.


Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security

Member of Alliance of Security Analysis Professionals

SpywareHammer

 

Free Internet Security - WOT Web of Trust

 

  • Post Points: 26
Muddy Yorkville
Joined on 06/07/2000
Posts: 4,997
Points 14,764

Re: On the sense and senselessness of Malware cleaning

Just playing devil's advocate here. I would certainly rely on the advice of a trained malware remover in the event.


Follow-up question: Do you know if a full backup by Acronis of a clean system to an external HD is immune to infection? It is stored as a compressed  *.tib file that I cannot scan with any of my AV/AS programs. Just idle curiosity, against a rainy day.


Free Internet Security - WOT Web of Trust    Use OpenDNS    Get WinPatrol Free    MalwareBytes' Anti-Malware Free

  • Post Points: 50
Joined on 02/11/2006
Posts: 17,261
Points 65,721

Re: On the sense and senselessness of Malware cleaning

If it's clean to begin with as you made the backup, I would think it would be okay. 


Microsoft MVP - Consumer Security

Member of Alliance of Security Analysis Professionals

SpywareHammer

 

Free Internet Security - WOT Web of Trust

 

  • Post Points: 26
Muddy Yorkville
Joined on 06/07/2000
Posts: 4,997
Points 14,764

Re: On the sense and senselessness of Malware cleaning

Thanks. It's one of those things you hope you never have to test. Acronis has a program to validate the integrity of the backup, but until you need it you never really know for sure.


Free Internet Security - WOT Web of Trust    Use OpenDNS    Get WinPatrol Free    MalwareBytes' Anti-Malware Free

  • Post Points: 23
 
Page 1 of 1