Print

Direct2Dell

Sign in
Sign in to post messages.
Austin, Texas
Joined on 04/10/2008 Posts: 426
Points: 9880
Silver

ATI CrossFireX – Dual 1GB ATI Radeon Mobility HD 4870 with GDDR3 memory

A few days ago I ran across an interesting thread on notebookreview.com, where Alienware customers noted some confusion regarding the graphics memory on the ATI HD 4870 in the Alienware M17x. Some folks were reporting that their invoices listed the memory as GDDR5 instead of GDDR3, and were wondering which memory was actually on the card.

 

Just to clear up any remaining confusion, the card definitely has GDDR3, *not* GDDR5.  While we’ve taken steps to correct the invoicing error, I hit up some folks from our engineering team to provide more detailed information on the subject.

 

The Alienware engineering team evaluated both GDDR5 and GDDR3 with the 4870 card.  Because of specific design constraints associated with notebooks and the 4870, they found that the GDDR3 memory provided the better overall user experience for gamers.  There are no current plans to offer GDDR5 in combination with a 4870 in the M17x.

Alienware will honor full refund requests for customers with incorrect invoices. I do recommend testing the cards for yourself before opting to return your M17x, though.  I think you may be pleased with the results

You must Login to comment.
  |  Del.icio.us   |  Digg   |  Reddit   | 

 

The 4870 GPU by nature is more limited by the memory bandwidth than the GPU speed (especially with GDDR3 instead of GDDR5).

 

So if someone buys an Alienware 17" laptop with dual 4870 GPUs, you can assume they want it for gaming and want a fast video solution. Limiting this solution with low bandwidth memory doesn't give them access to the full potential of their laptop.

 

GDDR5 may drain the battery faster than GDDR3 when idle, but a system like this would generally be used as a gaming desktop replacement, not a system that needs to last as long as possible on it's battery.

 

If heat is the problem, that might be a user experience issue, as the noise from the fans is a frequent complaint with laptops.