Print

Direct2Dell

Sign in
Sign in to post messages.
Chief Blogger
Joined on 06/29/2006 Posts: 1,959
Points: 187041
Gold

Dell IdeaStorm is Not a Digg Competitor

Since yesterday's blog post, the blogosphere reacted. Jeremiah Owyang and Marshall Kirkpatrick at Techcrunch both thought Dell IdeaStorm is a step in the right direction. However, some folks like Pete Cashmore at Mashable have said we're potentially creating another "Diggstorm in the making."

To Pete and to other Digg.com fans out there—we're fans too and think the folks at Digg have done a great job bringing an intuitive and useful voting model to the blogosphere. In our view, the voting functionality enhances what Dell IdeaStorm offers our customers. Voting provides an efficient way for our customers tell us what ideas they think are most important. That's why voting is part of IdeaStorm.

Dell IdeaStorm is not a news site. Its purpose is to allow customers to voice and discuss ideas that they'd like to see. We are not building a Digg competitor and have no intention to do so.

You must Login to comment.
  |  Del.icio.us   |  Digg   |  Reddit   | 

 
theodoremomoto
I'm feeling a bit ambivalent about your IdeaStorm idea. Good luck with it, though.
 
theodoremomoto
I'm feeling a bit ambivalent about your IdeaStorm idea. Good luck with it, though.
 
Ryan McCain
the duplicates make it almost unusable, however, its a great start.
 

FYI, I blogged about my perspective. Here's the shortcut URL

Dell Raises the Bar on Customer Engagement
http://snipurl.com/1b0ej

Regards, DHD

 
If only Dell would look at the Ideastorm site and maybe leave some feedback so we know they were there.  Better yet clean up the place its a mess with all the duplicate posts.
 
Cy Jervis: We're working on both, and have been merging duplicate ideas as quick as we can. Updates will be on the way soon.

 

I visited the IdeaStorm website.

I observed a problem.  The voting process is a positive vote.  There is no method for casting a negative vote.

Even visiting a topic appears to counted as a positive vote, such that the person reading the topic must be positively interested in the topic.

On the whole, most topics may actually be worthy of a positive vote, or positive interest.  But what happens when somebody starts an obnoxiously titled, misleading thread that catches the fancy of IdeaStorm readers?

What if some tightwad starts a topic that wants Dell to only install Pent 1 chips in every computer.  Again, readership could boost the topic to a highly read topic, even though the readership truly is only interested in reading the views of a complete idiot.

Dell needs to find a way to offer a reasonable balance of  opinions.  Everything can not be positive.

 
StevenD: Thanks for the feedback. We've received the same request from other readers. We're looking into it...

 
theodoremomoto
I'm feeling a bit ambivalent about your IdeaStorm idea. Good luck with it, though.
 
very nice
 

I like what you are doing here a lot...in fact, I blogged about it today at www.communitygrouptherapy.com.

 I'd "digg" talking to you guys about what you are doing here if you're interested. 

 Great start!

Sean

 

Stefan, I can tell you a secret:

Ethan (post above) is a dell account. Trying to get things back in line.....

Lenovo vs Dell. The winner is:

=> for sure: Dell

(even in quality, btw: its not TRUE!!)

 

 

 

Actually Stefan, throughout all my years of being a sysadmin, I've seen countless IBM (and now technically Lenovo) laptops broken in many ways I had not thought possible. While I have seen cases like that with Dell laptops, their computers tend to have a higher build quality in the long-run.

Plus, the fact that IBM had to sell their desktop and laptop lines to a foreign company just says that Dell was, and still is, doing a better job than IBM (and now Lenovo...) could ever fathom.

 

The only similarity is the voting system.

Last time I checked, Kevin didn't patent that, and he would be foolish to.

I still won't buy Dell's due to the fact that nothing you make comes close to a Lenovo Thinkpad X60s, but I do have to say props for what you're trying to do. 

 
I whole heartedly agree! It is something that will make the consumers even more happy.
 
I think it's a great idea!  I fully agree with this post.